Skip to main content

The Shortest Comments on Genesis, Chap. XXXII-XXXIII


The chosen fragment records ancient views on the symptoms, mechanism, and differential diagnosis of ligamentum capitis femoris (LCF) injury. The author describes the emotional status, work capacity of the patient, circumstances, time, and place of the injury, as a physician in the modern medical record (Genesis 32:8-33:20). Further in the text, apparently, a pathoanatomical investigation is mentioned, confirming the antemortem diagnosis, place of dissection (Genesis 50:2-3), as well as the location of the burial of embalmed remains (Genesis 50:13). Our comments on chapters 32-33 are presented in the table. The quotes are based on the translation of the Book of Bereshit (Genesis) from Hebrew by Isaac Leeser (1922).

The shortest comments

Quotes from the original source

Emotional status and the name of injured person.

32:8  Then  Jacob  was  greatly  afraid,  and  he  felt  distressed  ;  and  he  divided  the  people  that  were  with  him,  and  the  flocks,  and  the  herds,  and  the  camels,  into  two  bands. … 32:21  And  say  ye  moreover.  Behold,  also  thy  servant  Jacob  is  behind  us.  For  he  said,  I  will  appease  him  with  the  present  that  goeth  before  me,  and  afterward  I  will  see  his  face ;  peradventure  he  will  receive  me  kindly.

Time and circumstances of injury.

32:22  The  present  went  thus  on  before  him  and  he  lodged  himself  that  night  in  the  camp  32:23  And  he  rose  up  that  night,  and  he  took  his  two  wives,  and  his  two  women-servants,  and  his  eleven  sons,  and  passed  over  the  ford  of  the  Yabbok.  32:24  And  he  took  them,  and  sent  them  over  the  stream,  and  sent  over  what  he  had.

Symptom of damage: «pain while half asleep».

32:25  And  Jacob  was  left  alone;  and  there  wrestled  a  man  with  him  until  the  breaking  of  the  day.

Mechanism of injury.

32:26  And  when  he  saw  that  he  could  not  pre  vail  against  him,  he  struck  against  the  hollow of  his  thigh ;  and  the  hollow  of  Jacob's  thigh  was  put  out  of  joint,  as  he  was  wrestling  with  him.

Dream of the injured.

32:27  And  he  said,  Let  me  go,  for  the  day  hath  dawned.  And  he  said,  I  will  not  let  thee  go  until  thou  hast  blessed  me. … 32:30  And  Jacob  asked  him,  and  said.  Tell  me,  I  pray  thee,  thy  name.  And  he  said,  Wherefore  is  it  that  thou  dost  ask  after  my  name  ?   And  he  blessed  him  there.

Place of injury.

32:31  And  Jacob  called  the  name  of  the  place  Peniёl :  for  I  have  seen  an  angel  of  God  face  to  face,  and  my  life  hath  been  preserved.

Symptom of injury: «lameness».

32:32  And  the  sun  rose  unto  him  as  he  passed  by  Penuёl,  and  he  halted  upon  his  thigh.

Pathomorphology of injury.

32:33  Therefore  do  the  children  of  Israel  not  eat  the  sinew  which  shrank,  which  is  upon  the  hollow  of  the  thigh,  unto  this  day;  because  he  struck  against  the  hollow  of  Jacob's  thigh  on  the  sinew  that  shrank.

Meeting of Jacob and Esau.

33:1  And  Jacob  lifted  up  his  eyes,  and  looked,  and  behold,  Esau  came,  and  with  him  four  hundred  men.  And  he  divided  the  children  unto  Leäh,  and  unto  Rachel,  and  unto  the  two handmaids.  33:2  And  he  put  the  handmaids  and  their  children  foremost,  and  Leäh  and  her  children  after,  and  Rachel  and  Joseph  hindermost.

Differential diagnostic test.

33:3  And  he  himself  passed  on  before  them,  and  bowed  himself  to  the  ground  seven  times,  until  he  came  near  to  his  brother.

Dialogue between Jacob and Esau.

33:4  And  Esau  ran  to  meet  him,  and  embraced  him,  and  fell  on  his  neck,  and  kissed  him;  and  they  wept. … 33:11  Take,  I  pray  thee,  my  present  that  is  brought  to  thee;  because  God  hath  dealt  graciously  with  me,  and  because  I  have  a  plenty  of  all.  And  he  urged  him,  and  he  took  it.

Symptom: «prefers to sit».

33:12  And  he  said.  Let  us  depart,  and  move  farther,  and  I  will  travel  near  thee.

Symptom: «slow walking».

33:13  And  he  said  unto  him.  My  lord  knoweth  that  the  children  are  tender,  and  the  flocks  and  herds  with  young  are  a  charge  on  me : and  if  they  should  overdrive  them  one  day,  all  the  flock  would  die.  33:14  Let  my  lord,  I  pray  thee,  pass  on  before  his  servant :  and  I  will  lead  on  slowly,  according as  the  cattle  that  goeth  before  me  and  the  children  may  be  able  to  travel,  until  I come  unto  my  lord  unto  Seïr.

Parting of Jacob and Esau.

33:15  And  Esau  said.  Let  me,  I  pray  thee,  leave  with  thee  some  of  the  people  that  are  with  me.  And  he  said,  What  needeth  it?  let  me  only  find  grace  in  the  eyes  of  my  lord.  33:16  So  Esau  returned  that  day  on  his  way  unto  Seïr.

Work capacity in the first day after injury.

33:17  And  Jacob  journeyed  to  Succoth  and  built  himself  a  house,  and  for  his  cattle  he  made  booths;  therefore  he  called  the  name  of  the  place  Succoth.

Work capacity six months after injury.

33:18  And  Jacob  came  in  good  health  to  the  city  of  Shechem,  which  is  in  the  land  of  Canaan,  when  he  came  from  Padan-aram;  and  he  encamped  before  the  city. 33:19  And  he  bought  the  parcel  of  the  field,  where  he  had  spread  his  tent,  at  the  hand  of  the  children  of  Chamor,  the  father  of  Shechem,  for  a  hundred  kessitah.  33:20  And  he  erected  there  an  altar,  and  called  it,  El-Elohé-Yisrael.

Morphological verification of damage.

50:2  And  Joseph  commanded  his  servants  the physicians  to  embalm  his  father:  and  the  physicians  embalmed  Israel.

Place of the pathoanatomical examination.

50:3  And  they  fulfilled  for  him  forty  days;  for  so  they  fulfil  the  days  of  those  that  are  embalmed;  and  the  Egyptians  wept  for  him  seventy  days.

Location of the burial of embalmed remains.

50:13  And  his  sons  carried  him  into  the  land  of  Canaan,  and  buried  him  in  the  cave  of  the  field  of  Machpelah,  which  field  Abraham  bought  for  a  possession,  as  a  burying-place,  of  Ephron  the  Hittite,  before  Mamré.

For a more detailed discussion of the medical aspects of biblical trauma, refer to our book «Children of Human: The Origins of Biblical Legends in the View of a Physician» (2023АрхиповСВ [in Russian]).


References

Leeser I. The twenty-four books of the Holy Scriptures. Carefully translated according to the Massoretic text, on the basis of the English version after the best Jewish authorities and supplied with short explanatory notes by Isaac Leeser. New York: Bloch Pub. Co., 1922. [archive.org]

Архипов С.В. Дети человеческие: истоки библейских преданий в обозрении врача. Обновляемое электронное эссе, снабженное ссылками на интерактивный материал. Йоэнсуу: Издание Автора, 2023; версия 1.0.0. (Arkhipov S.V. Children of Human: The Origins of Biblical Legends in the View of a Physician. Updatable e-Essay with Links to Interactive Material. Joensuu: Author's Edition, 2023; Version 1.0.0. [In Russian]) [books.google]  

Keywords

synonyms, ligamentum capitis femoris, ligamentum teres, ligament of head of femur, Bible, anatomy, Torah, trauma, injury 

.                                                                     .

In translating to English, the author is assisted by ChatGPT (version 3.5) and the Google Translate service.

If you notice an error, please let us know!

NB! Fair practice / use: copied for the purposes of criticism, review, comment, research and private study in accordance with Copyright Laws of the US: 17 U.S.C. §107; Copyright Law of the EU: Dir. 2001/29/EC, art.5/3a,d; Copyright Law of the RU: ГК РФ ст.1274/1.1-2,7

BLOG CONTENT 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

University_of_Guelph(website)

  Content [i]   Annotation [ii]   Original text [iii]   Illustrations [iv]   Source  &  links [v]   Notes [vi]   Authors & Affiliations [vii]   Keywords [i]   Annotation A quote from an article on the University of Guelph website. The publication mentions the animal's ligamentum capitis femoris (LCF) and states its function: fixing the femoral head in the acetabulum. The text in Russian is available at the following link: University_of_Guelph(website) . [ii]   Original text Quote 1.  Hindlimb skeleton. Femur [animals]   The articular head of the femur is deeply rounded and it bears a round ligament that holds it into the acetabulum.   [iii]   Illustrations – [iv]   Source  &  links STRUCTURE OF THE SKELETON.  2023.   animalbiosciences.uoguelph.ca [v]   Notes The work  is cited in the following publications:  [vi]   Authors & Affiliations Unive...

280-352Rava

  Sayings of Rava extracted from the tractates Chullin and  Horayot  (Babylonian Talmud). Babylonian Talmud was written between about 450 - 550 in present-day Iraq (formerly Babylonia). The rabbi identifies the location and distal attachment site of the ligamentum capitis femoris (LCF) and demonstrates knowledge of its function.  See our commentary at the link:   280-352Rava [Rus]. Quote 1. [Heb] Chullin 54b3 (original source:  sefaria.org ) Quote 2. [Heb] Chullin 91a12 (original source:  sefaria.org ) Quote 3. [Heb] Horayot 12a:16 (original source:  sefaria.org ) Translation Quote 1. [Eng] Chullin 54b3 The Gemara addresses the matter itself: Rav Mattana says: This head of the femur that was completely dislocated renders the animal a tereifa. And Rava said: The animal is kosher, but if its sinew holding the bone in place is cut, it is a tereifa. The Gemara concludes: And the halakha is: Even if the sinew is cut, the animal is still kosher...

Human Children. Retelling of Chapter 8

  Short retelling of chapter 1 of the essay: Arkhipov S.V. Human Children: The Origins of Biblical Legends from a Physician's Perspective. Joensuu: Author's Edition, 2025. [In Russian]  Chapter 8. THE LAND OF NOD Cain’s family settled in the land of "Nod," where they established a "city." We propose this tribal group followed a route later known as the Great Khorasan Road, leading Cain, son of Adam, to the Kermanshah Valley in the central Zagros Mountains. There, we believe he founded the settlement of "Enoch," its remnants linked to the archaeological site of Sheikh-e Abad (34°36'42"N, 47°16'11"E). In this village, the newcomers mastered musical instruments, developed metalworking techniques, and some adopted nomadic herding, living in "tents with flocks." As a farmer, Cain likely preserved knowledge of agriculture. Favorable conditions, division of labor, and acquired skills probably fueled population growth among thes...

1220-1260Hezekiah ben Manoah

  Fragment from the book Hezekiah ben Manoah. Chizkuni (ca. 1240). Commentary on the Torah, was written in France between 1220-1260 ( jewishencyclopedia.com , sefaria.org ). The author briefly mentions ligamentum capitis femoris (LCF, גיד) of animals.  See our commentary at the link:   1220-1260Hezekiah ben Manoah [Rus]. Quote. [Heb] Chizkuni. Genesis 32:33.1 על כן לא יאכלו כמו והוא לא כן ידמה, כלומר בדין הוא שיש לקנוס ולענוש בני ישראל מאכילת גיד הנשה שהניחו את אביהם הולך יחידי כדכתיב ויותר יע קב לבדו (original source: sefaria.org ). Translation Quote. [Eng] Chizkuni. Genesis 32:33.1 על כן לא יאכלו, “therefore it is appropriate that the Israelites do not eat, etc.;” this construction is parallel to Isaiah 10,7: והוא לא כן ידמה, “but it does not seem like this to him;” in other words: it would be right and proper to punish the Israelites not to eat that particular sinew as they should not have allowed their founding father to be exposed to hostile forces at night.  (...

11th-15th Century

   11th-15th Century Catalog of archived publications of the specified period        11th century 976-1115Theophilus Protospatharius  The author writes about the  normal anatomy of the LCF and its connective function. 1012-1024Avicenna   The author writes about the localization and  variant of the pathology LCF, leading to hip dislocation. 1039-1065Giorgi Mtatsmindeli   The translator mentions the LCF damage, and notes its presence in animals. 12 th century 1120-1140Judah Halevi   The author mentions LCF (גיד) of mammals. 1176-1178(a)Rambam  The author mentions the pathology of LCF (גיד) in humans and points out the presence of this structure in animals. 1176-1178(b)Rambam  The author writes about the localization of LCF (גיד) ) and distinguishes it from a tendon,   blood vessel or nerve. 1185-1235David Kimchi  The author writes about the localization, purpose, and injury of the LCF (גיד), and also talks abo...

17th Century

  17th Century Catalog of archived publications of the specified period        1600-1609 1600LaurensA  The author writes about the anatomy, attachment, properties, shape and size LCF. 1603IngrassiaeIP  The author writes about the topography of LCF, its geometric and mechanical properties.  1605BauhinC  The author writes about the attachment, function, possible elongation and damage of the LCF.  1610-1619 1610RiolanJ   The author discusses the localization, function, attachment and mentions rare synonyms of LCF.  1611BartholinC  The author describes the anatomy, topography, geometric and mechanical properties of the LCF.  1611GuidiG  The author briefly writes about the anatomy,  function,  and attachment of the LCF.  1614PlatterF   The author notes the role of the LCF in fixing the femur in the acetabulum and the possibility of its lengthening. 1615BauhinC  The author describes the consist...

1996(f)ArkhipovSV

Hip prostheses (Эндопротез тазобедренного сустава) Patent Application RU96119857A Inventor Сергей Васильевич Архипов Original Assignee Sergey Vasilyevich Arkhipov Application RU96119857A/14A events 1996-10-01 Application filed by С.В. Архипов 1999-01-20 Publication of RU96119857A Claims Hip endoprosthesis comprising acetabular component formed as a bowl with a derotation protrusions on the outer surface, and a femoral component, characterized in that the inner spherically concave surface of the bowl has a shaped recess and the outer surface - shaped protrusion and a porous coating, the cup is provided with fastening elements and a flexible member, one end of which is fixed in the shaped recess and the other end connected to the femoral component. Description of the invention Description in Russian is available at the link: 1996(f) АрхиповСВ (the blog has a translation function).   External links:  Arkhipov SV. Hip prosthesis. Application for invention №96119857 (026178) date...

Main Functions of LCF

  Version : 20240419 MAIN FUNCTIONS OF LCF 1. Mechanical 2. Trophic 3. Sensory 4. Synthetic 5. Conductor The mechanical function of LCF involves the ability to perform work, change the direction and magnitude of movements, and convert potential energy into kinetic energy, which manifests in effects. The mechanical function is realized by the stroma of LCF. The trophic function of LCF involves providing nutrition and gas exchange in the medial part of the femoral head through the vascular system. The sensory function of LCF involves synthesizing and transmitting information to the central nervous system about the magnitude of mechanical stresses in the stroma and attachment areas, as well as about the parameters of the intra-articular environment of the joint. The sensory function is provided by nerves and receptors of LCF, in conjunction with analyzers of the spinal cord and brain. The synthetic function of LCF involves the production of synovial fluid, which redu...

PRE-SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE

  PRE-SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE   (Early non-scientific information and religious publications... ) 2016 CohenY  The first mention of LCF on an Akkadian cuneiform tablet 4000-3600 years old. 2018 CohenY  Discussion of the first mention of LCF in an Akkadian text from the period 2000-1600 BCE.    BLOG CONTENT

1510Leonardo_da_Vinci

  Drawing by Leonardo da Vinci «The bones and muscles of the leg (recto)». The work was created during the author's study of human anatomy in the winter of 1510-1511 in Milan. In the drawing, Leonardo da Vinci depicted the distal fragment of the ligamentum capitis femoris (LCF). See also the monograph 2013ClaytonM_PhiloR . Drawing Leonardo da Vinci.  The bones and muscles of the leg (c.1510-11 ) (© Royal Collection Enterprises Limited 2024  | Royal Collection Trust,  rct.uk ). Fragments External links Leonardo da Vinci. The bones and muscles of the leg (recto); The muscles of the shoulder, arm and neck (verso) c.1510-11. Black chalk, pen and ink, wash | 28.8 x 20.2 cm (sheet of paper) | RCIN 919008 [ rct.uk ].  © Royal Collection Enterprises Limited 2024 | Royal Collection Trust ( www.royalcollection.org.uk ) . Clayton M, Philo R. Leonardo da Vinci: The mechanics of man. London: Royal Collection Trust, 2013. Authors & Affiliations Leonardo da Vinci ( Leon...